Sunday, March 28, 2010

Greenberg



With its half-filled swimming pools, under-attended open mic nights and huddled masses of struggling actors, writers and musicians hovering around the city like day laborers outside of a Home Depot, Los Angeles has come to represent the place where dreams go to die as much as it does glamor and fame. It's where everyone begins their life as a wistful optimist but invariably ends up jaded or bunt-out. There's a lost souls quality to the people who live there, struggling and failing to live up to what they thought they'd be when they're surrounded by success and cruel reminders of the class and social divide. The characters in Greenberg, the new film from writer-director Noah Baumbach, have all, to varying degree, made their peace with the lives they've given up on and dreams they've abandoned in order to survive. It's a film about compromise and grudging acceptance.

The film stars Ben Stiller as Roger Greenberg--an asshole in the strictest, The Royal Tenenbaums, sense of the word--a single 40-year-old man housesitting in Hollywood while his successful and well adjusted brother spends six-weeks in Vietnam on vacation with his family on the sort of third third world jaunt that only the super-affluent consider a lark. At one point an up and coming musician, Roger now works, although seemingly not out of necessity, as a carpenter following a stint in a mental institution (this is the only part of the character which rings false; like Nicholson in As Good as it Gets, the film is trying to provide a medical explanation for a character who is, at his core, a self absorbed piece of shit).

Roger isn't an Angelino specifically. He grew up in LA then moved east and his time back on the west coast feels fleeting. Spiritually though, he fits right in. He's adrift, floating in between his old life and a next chapter he doggedly refuses to begin writing. It's as though Benjamin Braddock has aged twenty years but still can't be bothered to get out of the pool (in an ironic twist, Roger is a horrible swimmer). Returning to Southern California 15 years after blowing up his music career, his relationship with his ex (Jennifer Jason Leigh, also serving as one of the film's producers and story contributors) and his best friend Ivan (Rhys Ifans, a hollowed-out shell of a man, too lethargic to hold a grudge), Roger will tell anyone who will listen how happy he is "doing nothing," oblivious to how counter-intuitive that is to everyone around him. Having created a status quo where no one expects anything of him, Roger's entire life seems dedicated to professing his superiority to everyone else, despite scant evidence to back this assertion up.

Like a younger, furrier Larry David, Roger is a casual misanthrope and cruel observer of the human condition, calling out behavior and conversation that fail to adhere to his lofty standards, even when no one's asking for it. Receiving the brunt of Roger's unsolicited opinions is his brother's personal assistant Florence (Greta Gerwig), a gawky bundle of low self-esteem wrapped in vintage cardigans and worn-thin leggings. Florence inexplicably takes an interest in the open sewer of a man, despite being fifteen years his junior and most of his seduction attempts ending in unwarranted ridicule and passive aggressive criticism.

Florence views Roger as vulnerable and a wounded soul, but there's more to her attraction than pity. Herself an aspiring singer, reduced to running personal errands for someone else's family, Florence at 25, is compromised and confused, and perhaps a little damaged from her time spent alone in an indifferent city. Throwing herself at any man who shows her the slightest bit of attention and lacking the filter to keep inside all the overly sincere feelings she has, Florence recognizes in Roger a sense of confidence in who he is, even if who he is is a snarky, barking monster. In a place where everyone's trying to make it, is there value in someone who's comfortable with having already given up?

Greenberg slowly peels back Roger's unearned sense of entitlement, revealing it for all its laziness and selfishness; it's a cynical form of self-awareness cannibalizing itself until you can hardly remember what you're disaffected against. Roger feels about for reasons to douse his burgeoning relationship with Florence, ranging from lack of sexual attraction (equating her to someone who's pretty at the office but less so outside of it) to merely not wanting to put the effort into it. Yet there's a fumbling, messiness to their awkward trysts (the film contains, perhaps, the least erotic instance of cunnilingus I've ever seen), as though Roger can barely contain himself emotionally and physically when he's with her. As the film progresses, Roger's cruelty towards her seems less emblematic of his worldview than it is in response to allowing himself grow close to someone.

Greenberg follows Baumbach's The Squid & the Whale and Margot at the Wedding as his latest film about the awful things acidic, overly-educated types do to the people they love, and it's arguably darker than both of those films. Roger's anger feels genuinely born of disappointment and self-preservation but the film isn't interested in forcing redemption upon him. Instead Greenberg settles for an impasse between Roger's overworked id and the realization that he's alienated everyone around him. Like Baumbach's earlier films, the writing here is precise in the way language can draw blood. There's nothing cute or tittering about the film's verbal assaults and I'll confess to viewing large portions of the film hiding behind my outstretched fingers, as though I were watching a horror film. There's an integrity to the film, in allowing its lead character to be so unwaveringly unpleasant, but that in no way offsets the feeling of watching a slow motion car wreck.

Stiller has spent the better part of the past decade selling himself as a family friendly leading man, but anyone who's seen his brief stint on "Curb Your Enthusiasm" or hasn't forgotten that he directed the much loathed Jim Carrey misfire The Cable Guy, will instantly recognize a lacerating arrogance often barely held at bay. Similar to Adam Sandler in last year's unfortunately overlooked Funny People, this is brave, unsentimental work from a talented comedian rarely called upon to do more than act opposite cgi creatures and frequently mug for the camera. For those of us who have watched Stiller stand outside of material that appears beneath him for years now, it's something of a revelation to see him finally laid bare and fully engaged with his subject.

But the final word on Greenberg belongs to Gerwig, a mainstay of the "mumblecore" genre, here receiving the widest exposure of her career. The actress lacks the polish and photo-shopped veneer of a conventional starlet, instead lending the film an earnest gravity and earthy sexuality. Perhaps the greatest compliment I can pay the young actress is that there doesn't appear to be an actual performance taking place; Gerwig simply inhabits the role, forgoing all affectation or technique and flattening out the character's big emotional moments. It's an incredibly internalized piece of acting as we witness a woman entirely defined by her role as a submissive. A submissive to her career, a submissive to her surroundings, and ultimately one to her heart. Florence deserves better than Roger although seems unlikely to realize it. Roger recognizes that he doesn't deserve Florence; it's to his credit and the film's that he stops using this as an excuse.

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

[color=blue]Buy cheap Asacol without prescription. Asacol no rx needed cod accepted. Cheap Asacol cod saturday delivery.Asacol online fed ex.[/color]
 
[url=http://www.topmeds10.com/search.php?aid=89869&q=Asacol][img]http://aleksandrr.webng.com/viagra.gif[/img][/url]
 
[url=http://www.topmeds10.com/search.php?aid=89869&q=Asacol]Asacol[/url]-[b]CLICK HERE TO BUY ONLINE![/b]
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

[b]buy cheap Asacol cod free fedex.us Asacol cod sales.Asacol for cheap.Asacol without prescription overnight shipping.buy Asacol without a prescription or membership.buying Asacol overnight.buy Asacol next day delivery.purchase Asacol pharmacy online.Asacol without prescription.generic Asacol no prescription overnight.Asacol mg.buy online Asacol without prescription.buy Asacol online with overnight delivery.buy cheap Asacol without prescription.buy Asacol online.Asacol 2 business days delivery.order Asacol 2 days delivery.next day delivery Asacol.cod pay Asacol.Asacol no dr.buying Asacol.Asacol medication online.[/b]

Anonymous said...

[URL=http://imgwebsearch.com/35348/link/online%20dating/1_dating6.html][IMG]http://imgwebsearch.com/35348/img0/online%20dating/1_dating6.png[/IMG][/URL]

[URL=http://imgwebsearch.com/35348/link/online%20dating/2_dating6.html][IMG]http://imgwebsearch.com/35348/img0/online%20dating/2_dating6.png[/IMG][/URL]

[URL=http://imgwebsearch.com/35348/link/online%20dating/3_dating6.html][IMG]http://imgwebsearch.com/35348/img0/online%20dating/3_dating6.png[/IMG][/URL]

Anonymous said...

Hello there,

I have a message for the webmaster/admin here at andrewdignan.blogspot.com.

May I use some of the information from your blog post above if I give a backlink back to your site?

Thanks,
Thomas

Anonymous said...

I've had my iPad recompense yon 2 months minute and I'm letting the cat out of the bag you, Steve jobs certainly has his disposition of converting people to be a Mac/Apple fan. I own the iPad without 3G because I didn't hankering to entertain to pay for a supplemental specialty in rank to get the micro SIM card. So I've kinda reasonable lived with my iPad only where there's wifi connection. Which are aplenty anyway at Starbucks, Mcdonalds, and the libraries. This was previous to my benefactor introduced me to a great style around this problem -- a 3G wifi router AP that supports GPRS, GSM, WCDMA, HSUPA, HSDPA, UMT and LIMIT!

I purchased the [url=http://www.dealtoworld.com/goods-16971-Huawei+E5830+3G+WiFi+Router+AP+%28WCDMAHSUPAHSDPAUMTEDGEGPRSGSM%29.html]Huawei E5830 3G WiFi Router AP (WCDMA/HSUPA/HSDPA/UMT/EDGE/GPRS/GSM)[/url] from DealtoWorld.com, in the Networking group, under the control of my alter ego's encouragement, and I think he gets points or commission from my gain, since he's a DealtoWorld.com affiliate. The router AP is tremendously little, lightweight and convenient. So now I can weld to wifi anywhere with mp iPad! I no longer essential to pry into on a trip and low because a wifi AP at cafes etc. Nor spend so much of my shekels on caffeine overdose at Starbucks and other cafes. In addition, the 3G Wifi Router AP supports mignonne much all the bandwidths -- GPRS,GSM,WCDMA,HSUPA,HSDPA,UMT,EDGE. Take off a look at pictures I've uploaded of the Huawei 3G WiFi router that has made my fixation so much easier, and is promoting a healthier caffeine-free lifestyle. It proves that a geek lifestyle does not not bear to undertake hand in assistance with coffee.




And to think I was considering paying supplement to upgrade to the iPad that supports 3G! I'm so keen that that's not predetermined anymore with this 3G wifi router AP. I can right-minded tie together to the internet wherever I am with the Huawei 3G Wifi Router, as great as there is signal. This is not a technology creation per se, but it has certainly made my lifetime far more effectual! As well, I'm qualified to save my money that I would mostly disburse on Starbucks, McCafe, and other cafes with wifi! Which, through the conduct, makes me miracle whether it's a ploy by Steve Jobs, to prepare launched the 3G iPad portrayal only much later, so that wifi cafes can have a ball plenty of business from iPad wifi version. But I digress.

The 3G WiFi router AP I bought from [url=http://www.dealtoworld.com]DealtoWorld.com[/url] would possibly also be able to authorize to me download and play approximately with my apps on my iTouch, admitting that I haven't tried it yet. Shouldn't be a refractory I should think. This $100+ may be the superb money I've used up since it enables me to suffer with a sort of WiFi focus wherever I am. If I was more entrepreneurial, I can fifty-fifty start charging other geeks at cafes without WiFi for the benefit of present access to them. I'm steadfast I can undoubtedly draw back the $100 this go to pieces b yield! Alternatively, dialect mayhap I can start being an affiliate of DealtoWorld.com too, since I'm starting to come by more gadgets and tools there, and have been spreading little talk finish gather to my household and friends. Moreover, Christmas is coming in less than 2 months' patch, and I characterize as this Huawei 3G WiFi router would take in a gorgeous grant for many of my tech geek friends. I'm unswerving they'll also rise how shining and bold the router looks!

Anonymous said...

95326 Скачать Миссия Дарвина !)

Anonymous said...

код активации эроклассники !)







эроклассники 516498
942 эроклассники
эроклассники com 4392

Anonymous said...

кредит через вебмани =DD

Unknown said...

Strange to read about the film stars Ben Stiller as Roger Greenberg,also facts are also good to read.

__________________

BSC Dissertation

Free Poker Bankroll said...

This is really a fascinating website and all your articles, lots of useful stuff. One thing I just want to say is that your Punitive Superego Blog is so perfect to me.
--------------------------
Our www: Free Holdem Poker

Anonymous said...

pregnant clomid | clomid 25mg - order clomid online, arimidex vs clomid

Anonymous said...

arfe cialis , cialis , cialis sale , viagra , viagraprescriptioncheapestviagravut.com , viagra

Celesti Infinity said...

Ben Stiller as Roger Greenberg great performed. I
like the movie.